Picture this: you put down a $40,000 deposit on a pre-construction townhome in the South Okanagan. The developer breaks ground. You wait eighteen months. Then the project stalls. Financing dries up. The developer sends a cancellation notice — and buried on page 12 of the Purchase Agreement is a clause you didn't fully understand at signing.

That clause just made your situation a lot more complicated.

Pre-construction real estate can be a smart move — but it carries a distinct set of risks that standard resale transactions don't. The contract you're signing wasn't drafted by your lawyer. It was drafted by the developer's legal team, to protect the developer. And if things go sideways, the fine print decides who absorbs the loss.

In this guide, I'm breaking down exactly what clawback clauses are, when they get triggered, and what BC buyers — especially in the South Okanagan — need to know before putting pen to paper.

What Is a Pre-Construction Deal?

A pre-construction purchase — often called "pre-con" — means you're buying a property before it's been built. You sign a contract with the developer, pay a deposit (typically 5–20% of the purchase price), and wait for the project to complete — sometimes 12, sometimes 36 months later.

The appeal is real. You lock in today's price in a market that may appreciate before the keys are handed over. Some projects include assignment clauses that let you sell your purchase contract to another buyer before completion, potentially at a profit.

But here's the critical difference from a resale purchase: the contract you sign is not a standard BC Purchase Agreement. It's a developer-drafted document, often dozens of pages long, with Schedules and Addendums attached. The terms are set by the developer. Your negotiating power to change those terms is limited — and the risks that flow from them are entirely yours.

In BC, the Real Estate Development Marketing Act (REDMA) provides some baseline protections — including mandatory disclosure statements and limits on how deposits can be handled. But REDMA doesn't protect you from every clause a developer can write into a contract. That's where clawbacks come in.

What Is a Clawback Clause — and Why Does It Matter?

A clawback clause is a contractual provision that requires one party to return money they've already received, under specific conditions. In pre-construction real estate, these clauses typically show up in two places:

• In the buyer's agreement with the developer: If certain conditions aren't met — you default, the contract is cancelled, or developer-granted incentives are later disputed — you may be required to return pricing credits or upgrades that were issued as part of the deal. In a worst-case scenario, you may forfeit your deposit entirely.
• In agent commission agreements: Some developer co-op commission agreements include language that requires the buyer's agent to return their commission if the deal falls apart before completion — regardless of which party caused the collapse.

That second point affects you more than you might think. An agent operating under a clawback commission structure faces a personal financial risk every time they walk a client away from a deal that isn't right for them. That's a conflict of interest — a quiet one, but a real one.

"Clawback language is rarely the first thing highlighted at the presentation centre. It's buried in the Schedules — using phrases like 'subject to recapture' or 'incentive repayment provisions.' These phrases mean the same thing: under the right conditions, money changes direction — back to the developer."

When Do Clawback Clauses Get Triggered?

Clawback and deposit forfeiture clauses in BC pre-construction deals are typically triggered by one of four scenarios:

1. Buyer default at completion. If you can't close — financing fell through, your circumstances changed, you changed your mind — you risk forfeiting your full deposit and may face additional liability for losses the developer claims you caused.
2. Assignment clause violations. If you tried to assign your contract to another buyer and the developer didn't approve it, any proceeds from that attempted assignment may be clawed back — and you may face breach-of-contract exposure.
3. Developer-initiated cancellations with incentive disputes. When a developer cancels a project — often after years of delays — they may argue that pricing incentives, upgrades, or commission adjustments embedded in the original deal should be reversed, even though the buyer held up their end of the bargain.
4. Commission clawbacks. In co-op commission agreements, if the deal fails to complete for any reason — including developer cancellation — blanket clawback language can void the agent's commission entirely. This is a structural problem in how some developers draft their agent agreements.

The BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA) and REDMA set outer limits on how far developers can take this — but enforcement requires buyers and agents to know their rights and be willing to push back.

How Your Deposit Can Be at Risk

Under REDMA, deposits paid on pre-construction properties in BC must be held in a brokerage trust account — separate from the developer's operating funds — until rescission periods expire and statutory conditions are met. This provides a meaningful layer of protection.

But that protection has limits:

• Trust accounts only protect deposits until default. If you default as a buyer, the developer can claim your deposit as liquidated damages regardless of trust account rules. The trust account keeps your money safe from the developer's creditors — it doesn't keep it safe from the developer's legal team.
• Insolvency risk is real. If a developer becomes insolvent and the brokerage holding the trust account has not maintained proper controls — as recent BCFSA enforcement actions have highlighted — your deposit's security is only as strong as that brokerage's compliance record.
• Incentive clawbacks can increase your effective purchase price. Some developer contracts include "good-standing" provisions that allow them to claw back pricing credits if you're deemed to be in default — effectively raising the price you agreed to pay.

The bottom line: your deposit is safer in a properly maintained trust account than in a developer's operating account — but it is not immune to loss if the deal breaks down on your side of the table, or if the trust account isn't managed the way it's supposed to be.

What Happens to Your Agent's Commission?

This matters to you because it directly shapes the quality of advice you receive.

In most BC resale transactions, the buyer's agent receives a co-op commission from the listing brokerage — paid at completion, full stop. In pre-construction, the developer sets the commission terms independently. Those terms often include clawback provisions that agents working resale transactions never face.

If your agent knows their commission can be clawed back if the deal doesn't complete — even for reasons entirely outside their control — they may be less willing to raise red flags about the contract, push back on problematic terms, or advise you to walk away from a deal that doesn't serve your interests. That's not a commentary on any individual agent's integrity. It's a structural problem with how some developers draft their agreements.

The South Okanagan Pre-Construction Landscape

Pre-construction in the South Okanagan looks very different from Greater Vancouver or Kelowna. Project volumes are smaller, the developer landscape is more local, and the type of development — mostly strata townhome and small multi-family projects — carries its own risk profile.

That doesn't mean the risks disappear. It means they play out differently. A few realities worth understanding if you're considering a pre-con purchase in Penticton, Oliver, Osoyoos, or Summerland:

• Smaller developers mean less financial cushion. A local developer building 16 townhomes has significantly less capacity to absorb cost overruns, permit delays, or financing disruptions than a national builder with 400 units presold. If their construction loan comes under pressure, your project timeline — and your deposit — can be exposed.
• The current resale market offers real alternatives. With average days-on-market sitting between 80 and 90 days across the South Okanagan and genuine buyer leverage in most price brackets, the urgency to lock in a pre-con deal "before prices rise" is lower than developer sales teams tend to suggest.
• Local knowledge matters here. I know the developers active in this market, the project histories, and the brokerage trust account reputations. If there's a yellow flag on a new development — past project delays, litigation history, BCFSA filings — I can surface it quickly. That background check should happen before you pay a deposit, not after.

Red Flags to Watch For — and How to Protect Yourself

Not every pre-construction deal is a trap — but certain contract provisions deserve a very hard look:

1. Broad "force majeure" clauses that allow the developer to cancel the project for almost any reason while retaining the right to keep deposits or claw back incentives issued to buyers.
2. No firm completion date — or contracts that give the developer an unlimited extension window, measured in years rather than months, with no compensation to the buyer for carrying costs during the delay.
3. Assignment restrictions that prevent you from selling your contract if your circumstances change before completion. Life changes. Your contract should give you a reasonable exit option.
4. Commission clawback language in the co-op agreement. Ask your REALTOR® directly: what are the commission terms on this development, and is there a clawback provision?
5. No disclosure statement. Under REDMA, developers must provide a prospectus-style disclosure statement before you sign. If one isn't available — or the developer is pressuring you to sign before it's ready — that is a serious red flag.
6. Vague deposit trust provisions. Confirm in writing: which registered BC brokerage is holding your deposit, under what conditions it can be released to the developer, and what happens if the project is cancelled.

Before writing a deposit cheque on any pre-construction property in BC, work through this checklist:

• Request the full REDMA disclosure statement before signing anything. You have a statutory right to this document. If the developer won't provide it, walk away.
• Use your 7-day rescission period. BC law gives you 7 calendar days after receiving the disclosure statement to cancel without penalty. Do not waive this right.
• Have a BC real estate lawyer review the Purchase Agreement — specifically the Schedules and Addendums where clawback and deposit forfeiture language typically lives.
• Ask your REALTOR® about the commission structure — specifically whether there are clawback provisions in the co-op agreement.
• Confirm deposit trust account details in writing: which brokerage holds it, under what conditions it can be released, and what your recourse is if the developer becomes insolvent.
• Research the developer's track record: completed projects, BCFSA filings, litigation history, and references from previous buyers.
• Compare the pre-con deal to current resale inventory side by side. In today's South Okanagan market, resale often delivers better terms, faster possession, and dramatically lower contract risk.

Know What You're Signing Before You Sign It

Pre-construction can make sense for the right buyer, the right project, and the right developer. But "the right developer" and "the right contract" require verification — not trust.

The buyers who get hurt in these situations aren't naive or careless. They were given a lot of paper, not enough time, and a sales environment designed to move them toward a signature. The antidote isn't skepticism — it's preparation. Understand your rescission right. Get independent legal review. Choose a REALTOR® who has no financial reason to steer you in the wrong direction.

If you're weighing a pre-con opportunity in the South Okanagan — or just want a straight comparison of what's available in resale right now — I'm happy to look at the numbers with you. No pressure, no sales pitch. Just a clear picture of your options.

Riccardo (Rico) Manazza

REALTOR® · eXp Realty · My Property Central Real Estate Group · Licence RE603392

Rico is a licensed REALTOR® serving the South Okanagan from Osoyoos to Penticton, Oliver, Summerland, Keremeos, Princeton, and Hedley. He publishes weekly real estate content on livingintheokanagan.ca and YouTube, with a focus on data-driven advice and zero pressure.

📞 (236) 457-4230  |  ✉️ riccardo.manazza@exprealty.com

• LinkedIn
• Instagram
• Facebook
• YouTube